1st Strike: Kitten Muses Throw. Box of Lemonheads. Nightly deposit.
2nd Strike: Alligator Muses Throw. Penguin Muses Throw. Happy Feet Widescreen DVD. Box of Redhead Chewy Lemonhead & Friends. Nightly deposit.
The similarities are too well executed for this to be a copycat bandit. I suspect the addition of the DVD is meant to divert my attention, so that I spend all afternoon watching tap-dancing birds instead of solving the mystery. Who IS this elusive sprite?!??!??! Our experienced forensics teams tells us the transfer of gifts was perpetrated between midnight and 10 a.m. this morning.